Marriages & Killing Spree
Mary Ann got married for first time at the age of 20 to a labourer William Mowbray and the couple moved to South West England where she gave birth to her first child, a daughter named Margaret Jane. Another daughter was born two years later and when two more years passed, her first daughter Margaret died in 1860. Mary gave birth to two more children - a boy and a girl - over the next few years. In early 1965, her husband, William, died of an illness. Doctors said he died of gastric fever.
William was properly insured and Mary collected 35 Pounds on his death from the insurance company, British and Prudential Insurance Company. Mary moved to Seaham Harbour upon her husband’s death and started a love affair with Joseph Nattrass. Her daughter Margaret died of a sickness a few months later and Mary returned back to Sunderland, where she started working in an infirmary.
Mary’s good looks helped her with getting the attention of George Ward, who happened to be one of the patients in the infirmary, where she worked as a nurse. The couple dated for some time and got married in August 1965. Roughly a year later, George succumbed to an illness with symptoms of paralyzed body and intestinal infections. English Cholera was found out to be the cause by the doctors who said that he had been suffering from the illness since a very long time, but even then, they said his sudden death was surprising, but no suspicions were raised. Mary Ann took the insurance money and started a relationship with a widower, James Robinson.
Mary was hired by James as a housekeeper, who had a son, John Robinson, from his previous marriage. Soon, sis son died of gastric fever, breaking James emotionally. Mary came ahead to comfort him and ended up getting pregnant.
In 1866, she heard the news about her mother getting severely ill with hepatitis, and although she was recovering, Mary still went to see her. Suddenly, her mother started complaining of stomach cramps and died in the spring of 1867.
A few months later, Mary married James in a church and gave birth to a daughter Isabella Margaret, who died sometime later in 1868. The next year, Mary gave birth to another child, this time a boy, named George. Somehow, James grew suspicious of his wife’s bad intents and after confirming his doubts, he threw her out of his house and didn’t let her take the custody of their son, George.
Mary became bankrupt and started living on the streets when one of her friends, Margaret, introduced Mary to her brother, Frederick Cotton, also a newly widower. He fathered two children, Charles and Frederick Jr., who were getting looked after by Margaret, their aunt, who, quite obviously, died of a stomach related illness. Mary took the charge of consoling Frederick Sr. and became pregnant with his child. They got married and Mary gave birth to his son, George.
Mary came to know that one of her former lovers, Joseph Nattrass, was living a few kilometres away and to rekindle a relationship, Mary manipulated her husband to go to the village where Joseph lived. Frederick got ill from ‘gastric fever’ sometime later and died. Mary took the insurance money and started a relationship with Nattrass, who also died sometime later of gastric fever!
Thomas Riley was the first person to sense something off about her history and one day, flowing with overconfidence resulting from her past triumphs, she told him that the last living boy from the Cotton family, Charles, will die like his family, from ‘gastric fever’. Charles’ death compelled Riley to go to the local police station and he requested that the death certificate shouldn’t be made until his death gets properly investigated. A further investigation ensued when Mary made a phone call to the insurance office rather than doctor’s clinic.